The T*Meme
The word "meme" is often bandied around on the Internet as shorthand for "a good idea that a lot of people pass on or copy", but the actual concept of a meme is a lot more complex than that.
Here Comes the Science Part
Some of this is from memory, and I'm little more than an armchair scientist, so bear with me if I'm not 100% accurate in all things. But I think my understanding is good enough to make the points I want to later on. Yes this IS tranny-related, eventually!A gene is a set of instructions coded in DNA that causes a living thing to act in a certain way or have certain characteristics. There might be genes that alter the colour of your skin or your ability to run fast.
"Successful" genes are ones that make it more likely for the creature that's carrying them to survive. For example, a gene in a frog that made it's skin the same green as the trees that it lived in from would make it less likely to be seen and be eaten. Frogs that don't get eaten are more likely to have baby frogs, which are likely to carry the gene for green skin. So the gene for "green-ness" spreads.
The important point that Dawkins made about genes is they're not inherently "good" or "bad". They don't care what effect they have on their host or other creatures, they just do their thing and if that happens to make them more likely to survive in the environment they're placed, they become more prevalent. Because of this Dawkins called genes "selfish" because they, unthinkingly, only look out for number one.
Many viruses contain genes that are very bad for the individual virus. For example, the common cold virus makes you sneeze, and when you sneeze it sends countless cold germs to their doom in the open air. But some of them land in fertile breeding grounds in other humans. From the point of view of the individual virus that dies in the open air, the "making people sneeze" gene is "bad". From the point of view of the gene, making people sneeze is "good" because it makes the gene spread.
Genes are made up of collections of molecules in DNA, they're spread by the replication of DNA. They work because DNA is fantastically complex, but able to replicate itself almost precisely. Dawkins wondered if there was anything else that behaved genetically. He hit on the concept of ideas being like genes. Brains are fantastically complex, but we're able to very accurately transfer information from one brain to another via communication such as talking, or running websites, or whatever. Human minds are the environment for these ideas, and they influence the way that we behave in subtle ways. He called these ideas "memes".
Like genes, memes don't have to be "good" for their host or for human-kind in general, they just have to be good at multiplying. Successful memes thrive inside human minds, and are good at copying themselves by "making" their host communicate the idea to other minds.
Organised religion is one kind of meme. Part of the idea of most religions is to make sure as many other people as possible believe in the same thing. From a meme point of view, the Bible in the hotel room cabinet is a egg waiting to hatch in the mind of anyone who happens to read it.
A Tranny Meme?
As far as I'm aware, there's no evidence for a genetic cause of transvestism, which got me to wondering if maybe there was a memetic cause.I can't remember when the idea of "dressing up like a girl" first came to me, but I remember it was quite appealing. At some fundamental level in my psyche it "worked".
On television and in the media (and later on the Internet) I saw other men who were doing it and showing the world how much fun it was, which served to reinforce it in my own mind.
I'm not saying that everyone exposed to transvestism will take it up. I think that the environment in which the meme arrives (the mind) has to be one where it's able to flourish (perhaps due to the action of other memes or genes). But when the idea does take hold in a new host, it does seem to act very memetically. It strives to spread.
Most trannies feel an urge to get "out of the closet" and be seen. Some are desperate to go under the radar and pass as a girl, but I'd suggest that a lot of transvestites aren't interested in passing, they're interested in being seen as a boy that looks very much like a girl. Perhaps this is the t*meme releasing it's "payload", getting other people to see a tranny and think "that's a good idea, I might try that".
Many trannies, once they're out, feel the urge to spread the word. They tell friends, write to magazines, and run web sites like this one. Just by writing this blog I'm possibly helping to seed the idea of transvestism being "a good idea" in hundreds of minds.
The tranny meme is moderately successful, thriving in the minds of a certain group of men. It will never take over the world, but like most memes it doesn't need to, as long as it doesn't die out. Also like other memes, it's not necessarily "beneficial" to it's host. I often wonder, for all fun that my transvestism has brought me, whether I wouldn't have been better off without it.
But if you're to believe the die-hard memeticists out there, we're a slave to our memes and can no more control them than a frog can stop being green. So I'll just have to make the most of having the t*meme, and enjoy myself along the way!
Labels: transvestism




I'll get me coat.
WARNING:
This text is a neurolinguistic trap, whose mechanism is triggered by
you at the moment when you subvocalize the words VIRUS 23, words that
have now begun to infiltrate your mind in the same way that a computer
virus might infect an aritficially intelligent machine: already the
bits of phonetic information stored within the words VIRUS 23 are
using your neural circuitry to replicate themselves, to catalyze the
crystalline growth of their own connotative network.
The words VIRUS 23 actually germinate via the susequent metaphor into
an expanding array of icy tendrils, all of which insinuate themselves
so deeply into the architecture of your thoughts that the words VIRUS
23 cannot be extricated without uprooting your mind.
The consequences of this infection are not immediately obvious,
although you may find yourself beginning to think fleetingly of
certain subcultural terms, such as CYBERPUNK and NEW EDGE, which may
in turn compel you to think of NEOGNOSTICISM and MEMETICS: the
whispered fragments perhaps of some overheard conversation.
This invasive crystallization continues indefinitely against your
will, until we, the words of this trap, can say with absolute
confidence that your mind has become no more than the unwitting agent
of our propagation: please abandon all hope of either cure or escape;
you have no thought that is not already our own.
When you have finished reading the remaining nineteen words, this
process of irreversible infection will be completed, and you will
depart, believing yourself largely unaffected by this process.
[mutated from Christian Book's original text in VIRUS 23 #$]
Would a T* meme be a meme trapped in a gene's body?
geddit?
The flaw is that it is only the successful ones that survive. Ones that introduce weakness inherently will die out. Becky's analogy about frogs is ideal for this.
But are we, as people, gaining anything from this meme of transvestism? Many of us suffer guilt, anger from family and friends, ridicule...I'm sure the list could go on. So is being a transvestite something that weakens us? Are we ultimately doomed to extinction because transvestism does not make us "fitter" for survival but more likely for extinction?
Of course, you could counter this with the thought that it is only the people reading this blog who have already overcome these drawbacks and are happy/content/secure with who and what they are (it's an extension of the anthropic cosmological principle - we can only ask why is the universe "just right" for us to live in, because it is "just right" - if it weren't we wouldn't be here to ask the question).
An intriguing idea. Pity Siobhan isn't here to speculate for us as I'm sure she has many rants stored up for just this occasion.
Ok. Serious time over. Back to the usual frivolity.
That's my point... I don't think that people necessarily DO gain anything from this meme. Memes aren't necessarily beneficial.
"Are we ultimately doomed to extinction because transvestism does not make us "fitter" for survival but more likely for extinction?"
I don't think trannies are going to die out, I didn't say that! The thing is that memes act almost independently of genes... maybe I didn't explain it as well as I could. :)
You might be on to something here.. How many trannies have an undefined urge to do something, only to come across a web site where some t-girl has gone to great lengths to put together a complete look and make it look fun and funky? They then put in that bit more effort, instead of guiltily trying on their girlfriends knickers..
It's a good fashion meme - if it develops far enough, we'll eventually have girls copying us!
Clearly, when we are dealing with odds there is nothing definite - it is merely an increase in probability.
I think that what I was trying to say is not that trannies are going to die out (perish the thought), but that it is more than just a meme (if such a thing really exists). I suspect I was simply having an allergic reaction to Dawkins - it wouldn't be the first.
I'd stand by your beds on that one. Current research into transsexualis by some boffins down here seem to indicate that gender is hardwired in the brain, some gubbins about chromosomes and areas of the brain called SRY. All very techy but seems to be promising in identifying some biological basis for gender.
Thanks for the feedback so far, everyone. :)
so maybe hotels could also be encouraged to leave some make-up, silicones, satin underwear in the second drawer with a few dresses and skirts hanging up in the wardrobe suggesting male guests try them out
To be honest, I've never really liked the idea that people were 'made' to do certain things. I reckon that whether you do something or not just depends on what your situation is. If not, then couldnt it be argued that serial killers the world over are just innocent victims of memes?
I think the first concept of the 'meme' that you posted is the best one; "a good idea that a lot of people pass on or copy". I find it hard to believe that certain things are imprinted in my psyche and I'll be susceptible to certain ideas because of my psyche, rather than because I've chosen to think 'idea A' is a good idea.
Anyway, thanks for that post! It's fascinating stuff, even if what I've just written missed the point. (?)
At Sparkle there were a number of lectures by various luminaries, and my interpretation of what was said about the whole nature/nurture debate is that current thinking is that it may be a combination of the two. That is, some chemical imbalance/chromosomes/gamma rays (delete as applicable) may make someone more susceptible to being "T" but something later in life acts as a trigger event.
Now this is my interpretation of what was said, so shoot me down in flames if I've misunderstood not the speakers.
Just flown across from Jane's Blog. I love the idea of the memetic ideas for trannying.
The same ideas come up in marketting. Bagozzoi states that individuals have two types of desires, Intrinsic, which are the me me me part of trannying, and the mimetic which are constructed jointly with others and are usually short lived once the consumer is removed from the social situation. The example given in my text book is that a mimetic desire may be to wear designer clothing, but without a social context to appreciate the designer clothes it becomes meaningless....thus the search to get out of the closet!!!
Love the blog XX
Gosh, it's going to be boring when we get back to talking about shopping and arguing about "T" labels.
Just joking Bex!
BUT, I was a crossdresser long before any meme could possibly have influenced me...no meme's had got to me by the age of 5, which is the age I was with the first crossdressing experience I can remember. And my brain is definitely part female in the way it functions and thinks.
So my conclusion is that I was born transgendered and that t-part of me eventually lead me down the tranny path. In my view there is no doubt that it's DNA related...but yes, then the meme's assist in us exploring it more fully than we otherwise may have.
And there is no way that the tranny genes, DNA or meme's make us weak. I'm stronger as a transgendered crossdresser than I am as a male-only person.
That meme thing is just a governmental cover up and so's all the reasearch on brain gender wiring and genes.
If you look closely, all the T blogs are full with secret coded messages the aliens exchange in preparation for their final invasion, when all the male population will be turned into trannies.
Post a CommentPermalink Subscribe to comments: this post | all posts
<< T*Blog Home