Previous Posts

Subscribe

Basic feed (just the blog)

The Uberfeed (blog, pics & links)

Via e-mail:

Becky's T-Blog

Friday, February 09, 2007

Taking the pith

Today I had one of those great little flights of fancy and discovery that the internet can send you on.

It started with a cartoon in my Gary Larson desk calendar, featuring two frogs in a car. One (with tear-shaped fancy glasses, so obviously female) is berating the other for driving badly. She accuses the other of "driving like he's been pithed".

I've been a fan of Gary Larson since my early teens, and I must have seen that cartoon a dozen times in various calendars and collections, and every time I didn't quite get it. Was it supposed to be a pun on the words "pissed"? But that didn't make sense, because Americans tend to use the word pissed in the sense of "pissed off", meaning angry. I think it's only really in Britain that pissed also means "drunk". Anyway, "driving like you've been pissed" doesn't make any sense, and why would a frog lisp?

It was obvious I was on completely the wrong track. When I was a teen I'd let it slide and move on to the next cartoon. Today I decided to make use of the sum of human knowledge represented as a little orange fox on my start menu.

It turns out that "pithing" is what you do when dissecting a frog, sever it's spinal cord to render it immobile and senseless. It seems to be a common element in biology lessons in US high schools, which is probably why Larson used the word.

I've never cut open a frog, and I don't know anyone who has. It's not part of the UK Biology curriculum, as far as I'm aware (Joanna might correct me on that). All I really know about it is from watching that bit in ET where the kid sets all the frogs free. I needed to know more.

Extra internet research turned up the web site for The Frog Anti-Pithing Campaign. Which explains the "barbaric" practice in more detail and tries to rally other anti-pithers to get it banned.

Read that site, it really is quite enjoyable. Before I go on, I'd like to say that I don't necessarily disagree with it's author (frog dissection does sound very unnecessary in this day and age), but I still got a lot of laughs out of his arguments.

I'll quote you some of the best bits:
"Pithing a frog is much more horrorful (sic) than gassing a Jew (sorry, dear Jews, no offense intended, we are only trying to emphasize the horror of pithing a frog)"
Not content with equating Jews with frogs, the author makes other comparisons...
"Compare this to slavery, please: Slavery sounds so cozy and warm compared to a frog being pithed and dissected while alive! (Think of the frog as a human and you'll begin to grasp the horror of it all.)"

Wow, you're right! Picturing non-human things as humans does make situations quite horrific! I just mentally pictured One Man and His Dog with humans instead of dogs! Naked humans being forced to run around fields and herd sheep!! I was physically sick!!!

Then we get to The Campaign. The author urges us to get in contact with our local politicians to complain about pithing. He offers some helpful advice:
"It is quite easy to word letters to politicians, simply imagine you're writing your daughter, and that she's loosing it somehow."
So, I've decided to do my bit...

An Open Letter to the Rt Hon. Tony Blair MP
Dear Tony,

I'm very disappointed in you, young lady! Who was that man I saw you with on Thursday? Are you doing drugs? Do you want to get pregnant? Do you? Do you?

What happened to the little girl who I used to bounce on my knee?

Your mother and I are very disappointed with you. We love you really, you just worry us so much sometimes.

Love,

Becky xxx

P.S. Oh yeah, and can you do something about cutting up frogs? Thanks!
Anonymous Beki  Now you're just taking the pith.

Sorry, but I had to get it in before someone else did.

You want to be a bit careful though, animal right's people can be complete nutters. The letter bombs that went off about 3 weeks ago were suspected to be by them. 
Blogger Siobhan Curran  /me prods Beki in the ribs, points at the title, and edges away slowly 
Anonymous Alli' Cat'  :D
(what - no "pith" tag?) 
Blogger Selina  Anyway, Tony Blair is MP for Sedgefield so he's not your MP. Really Becky, sometimes you take things a bit too far.... 
Blogger Lynn Jones  Pithing, medical disclocation, exsanguination, death by exposure. All in a day's work for some..... 
Blogger Becky  Selina: I never pretended he was my MP. The article makes it clear you should also write to the president/prime minister of your country! :-P 
Anonymous Sirena  Hey! I have a Gary Larson desktop calendar, too! :D

"Foster! You better get over here if you want to see Meeher's hangnail magnified 500 times." :) 
Blogger Becky  Heheh. :-) Christmas present too, Sirena? It's nice to have the calendar back for a charity special, even if it is all old cartoons! 
Anonymous Beki  @Siobhan - Yes, I probably should have read the title first... 
Blogger Becky  Happens to us all, Beki. :-) 
Anonymous www.flickr.com/photos/bekiwithani  I seem to have this mental block, where I don't actually read things and just see what I want to see... 
Anonymous Beki  Gah! See! I did it again! 
Blogger Joanna  Dissecting whole animals is not part of GCSE any more, I don't even think its part of A Level. Although we do cut up animal parts such as heart, lungs and if you are very lucky a 'pluck' that is heart, lungs and tongue plus associated tubing all in one.

Bulls Eyes don't tend to be done now due to fears of cow disease.

When I was at Uni one frog dissection went quite awry when the solution we were using to bathe the frogs was contaminated with too much sodium causing the nerves to fire. All these very very dead frogs twitching away was quite disconcerting :)

Check out www.froguts.com for a good virtual frog dissection that we often use instead.

and wow... word verification for the day is 'bumkoq'.. that's a bit rude... 
Blogger Becky  Thanks Jo. :-)

The anti-pithing website also mentions Froguts. One thing I can't quite understand. I assumed frog dissection was intended to teach anatomy by using a creature that was basically similar to other animals, and not because people actually needed to know how frogs work?

So if you're going to simulate a dissection, why not use a human instead of a frog? :-) 
Blogger Joanna  Traditionally it was frogs or rats since they are easy to mass produce and are not too big or too small. I think there are stricter rules on keeping mammals so frogs tended to be the main thing used in biology classes. But the principle is that basic vertebrate physiology is very similar, although not exactly the same as a human.

But yeah, if you could run a simulation a human would be quite fun... 
Blogger Jane  Never mind squeamishness at using real frogs have you seen how much that service costs to subscribe to? Shocking. 
Blogger Jessica Hart  I recall, vaugely, doing the frog thing in science at school but that was some consdiderable years ago. If I recall correctly the frog was an offical experiment - th same day, whilst wingnut's (the science teacher - kinda had the old Prince of Wales ears) back was turned we also ried another unofficial experiment - sticking a pair of ail scissors into a 13am socket and switching it on.... 
Anonymous NH  The holocaust? Slavery? Frogs? I can see a whole raft of movies coming out in the wake of this:

SCHINDLER'S TOADS
"Ah, Herr Schindler...do you not find these betrachians so slimy, disgusting and sub-human, nicht wa?"

"If only I could have saved more! Then the swamps would be alive! I could have saved more!"

RIBBIT: One Frog's Search For His Origins
"Your name is Toby!"
"RIBBIT!"
"Dammit! It's not Ribbit! It's Toby!"
"RIBBIT!"
"Fetch the whip; it's the only language they understand"

UNCLE FREDDO'S LILY PAD:
"Oh Masser Freddo, them bad men from da plantation dey wanna take yus away an' give ya a good lynchin'!"

(OK, that's enough movie/frog parody...Ed) 
OpenID mr-cheeze  Haha, I came here after the blurb under your Google hit said "Killing frogs is worse than gassing Jews." I'm glad to see you were quoting someone else, and disagreeing. 

Post a CommentPermalink     Subscribe to comments: this post | all posts

<< T*Blog Home