Previous Posts

Subscribe

Basic feed (just the blog)

The Uberfeed (blog, pics & links)

Via e-mail:

04.05  05.05  06.05  07.05  08.05  09.05  10.05  11.05  12.05  01.06  02.06  03.06  04.06  05.06  06.06  07.06  08.06  09.06  10.06  11.06  12.06  01.07  02.07  03.07  04.07  05.07  06.07  07.07  08.07  09.07  10.07  11.07  12.07 

Advertise on Becky's Web

Becky's T-Blog

Wednesday, July 11, 2007

On muggles

On the eve of the last book and the latest film in the Harry Potter franchise, can I launch a campaign to expunge a particularly irksome Potterism from the Tranny Lexicon?

The word is muggle.

In the Potter universe it's uttered to describe non-magical humans, i.e. most of us. It's an ugly-sounding word, and it's designed to be. It's used normally in a derogatory sense. Muggles are generally seen as bland, ordinary and so stupid as to not realise the whole magical sub-culture of witches and wizards going on under their very noses.

In trannydom the word seems to have been adopted to mean "non-trannies", i.e. everyone supposedly not blessed with the magical ability to tip-toe merrily across the gender divide, like a wizard tip-toes merrily through brick walls at train stations (you can't tell I've only read one book, can you?).

To my ear, the tranny muggle still has the derogatory connotations of the Harry Potter muggle. It smacks of an elite looking down on a lesser class of people. I can kind of understand how it's a reaction by trannies who want to overturn the misconception that they are a lesser class of person, but I still think it's misguided.

And I don't really see why we need a word, when there's a perfectly suitable, albeit hyphenated, one in the form of "non-tranny". Or, how about this radical idea? Just call them people, which is what they are.

I'm sounding terribly lefty and right-on, aren't I? :-S

Let me phrase it another way for the trannies who are reading: we all know we're a little bit special, we don't need to rub it in to all those who aren't!

And to the non-trannies reading: Call me a tranny if you like, because that's what I call myself, but if you don't use derogatory words for me, then I'll practice the same courtesy to you. :-)

Labels: ,

Billy  Did you know that "muggles" was Louise Armstrong's slang word for marijuana.

He even did a song about it. 
Billy  Louise?????

I of course meant "Louis" 
Joanna  Louise Armstrong had real trouble passing.

I think the voice didn't help. 
Kat  And it's also been the topic of debate over here:

http://www.myhusbandbetty.com/community/showthread.php?t=8898&highlight=Muggles

Great minds and all that 
Penny M  This is political correctness gone mad, why oh why... (complete this yourself using any old copy of the Daily Mail).

But Becky, if we don't call them muggles, what else can we call non-trannies? We need something that describes what they are in relation to trannies for when we are talking about being amongst them, something that pertains to our transgender yet negates it. I've racked my brains and I can't think of another way of describing non-trannies 
Becky  What's wrong with "non-trannies"? :-)

Or invent a new word, I'm not saying there shouldn't necessarily be a word, I just think "muggles" is horrible and insulting. 
Paula Jayne  "NONIES" 
Pandora Caitiff  Having been part of other secret elitist communities (roleplayers, anime fans, classical music buffs etc) I like the term "mundanes".

OK, its slightly derogatory depending on inflection, but its main meaning is 'those people not aware of the magical beings who live right under their noses'. 
Penny M  "What's wrong with "non-trannies"? :-)"

Damn, I wasn't obvious enough, this humour thing is very complicated :-( 
Becky  In retrospect I get it, Penny. :D 
Siobhan  I concur, and would like to add a lot of other words to that list 
Lynn Jones  > mundanes.

Is that a Shadowrun or WoD reference?

I tend to use 'Joe Public' or 'you normal folk' most of the time. Course, what's normal nowadays? :) 
Gordon  Call us what you like. Seriously, muggle, non-trannie, whatevah (!).

Part of me is intrigued whenever this kind of thing comes up, and I think I understand the rationale behind it (but it can be hard being a middle of the road joe average sometimes, and as such I haven't gone through any of these processes other than in my head).

Sticks and stones and all that, innit? 
NH  Role players are an elite????? 
Gillian  errrrr, did I start this?? not that I get out much but I started using this before I heard anyone else use it.

I like it, it's comfortable and friendly and I don't see it as insulting at all, we're blokes in frocks, not something generally acknowledged to give you a whopping great superiority complex 
Siobhan  Can we call them 'Men'? 
Pandora Caitiff  Lynn - Its WoD. A related term is "consor" or "kinfolk" someone who isn't a *whatever* but understands the issue and is part of the *whatever* community

NH - I said we were *elitist* not elite :) 
Deacon Barry  Mundanes is a Xanth reference, from the series written by Piers Anthony. 
Anonymous  Fiona said

How about greys 

Post a CommentPermalink     Subscribe to comments: this post | all posts

<< T*Blog Home